Palestinian - Israeli Impasse - Exploring Alternative Solutions to the Palestine Israel Conflict

Date:
Aug. 1, 2005
Language:
English

Overview

In 2004, when it became clear that Palestinian-Israeli relations had reached a deadlock – there had not been any serious negotiations for over three years, an “Intifada culture” was prevailing, and daily lives were determined by the Israeli re-occupation of Palestinian cities, military in­cursions, and closure policies - PASSIA initiated a new project entitled Palestinian-Israeli Impasse - Exploring Solutions to the Palestine-Israel Conflict, in a search for the light at the end of the tunnel.

Stuck in a conflict that has been continuing for more than a hundred years, in which scores of mediators and proposals were unable to de­liver a solution, and left with the equally unsuccessful more recent initia­tives (e.g., the Clinton parameters of 2000, the Taba talks of 2001, the road map of 2002-3, the Nusseibeh-Ayalon Plan and the Geneva Ac­cords of 2003), common analysis had it that it was becoming increasingly likely that confrontation and bloodshed would continue and even inten­sify in the absence of any practicable alternatives.

As also the international community had proven unable to bring about a settlement consistent with international law and UN resolutions, an in­creasing number of voices claim that the two-state solution – a viable Palestinian state alongside Israel as pursued in various forms over the last five decades – had been effectively pre-empted by the deliberate policies and strategies of recent Israeli governments.

Against this background, PASSIA embarked on this project with the in­tention to promote serious dialogue and discussion about the various options facing the two communities over the course of the next few years, and to ex­amine whether, or to which degree, the two-state con­sensus is “dead,” what lies ahead if the status quo would last for another ten years, and what alternative proposals could or should be con­sidered. The project combined research (position pa­pers) and dialogue sessions (roundtables in which the papers were presented and dis­cussed) with an array of Palestinian scholars, intellectuals, members of government and of various political factions, NGO activists, and profes­sionals as well as Israeli academics and activists.

The papers included in this volume look at the reasons the two-state solution has failed to succeed until the present day and con­sider what prospects for future success or failure it still has, thereby looking at the issue from various angles (historical, conceptual and religious aspects; implications for the refu­gee question, Jerusalem, the settlement issue and the future geography of Pales­tine/Israel) .

The various proposed approaches to solve the Palestinian-Israeli impasse explored in this volume were provoked by a number of concrete questions, such as whether there is still a possibility for a (short-term or permanent) two-state solution; how the two-state solution should be reevaluated, given that all recent breakthroughs in the reconciliation process of inter-communal or ethnic disputes (Northern Ireland, South Africa, Bosnia) have been based on federal, consociational, and autonomy arrange­ments, and not on partition; and what kind of practicable models could be envisioned for the Palestinian-Israeli case.

For those papers that support the idea of a one-state solution, the pos­sibilities of maintaining separate cultures, heritages and identities while holding equal citizenships and rights in a democratic political system on one open territory are considered very seriously. By exploring these and related issues, the PASSIA team aimed to assess the positions adopted by different national, religious, secular and other groups on the various formulas as well as the greatest obstacles to each of them.

It is hoped that this volume will further contribute to the objectives of the project, which were to stimulate debate among people from different backgrounds and political affiliations on alternative agendas to overcome the current status quo and provide a forum for open discus­sion and exchange on those and related topics.

Jerusalem, May 2005

Dr. Mahdi Abdul Hadi (Editor)
Head of Passia

Contents
i

Introduction

iii

Paper Abstracts

1-18

Dreaming of Co-existence: A Brief History of the Bi-national Idea

Nick Kardahji

19-44

The Bi-National Solution for the Israeli-Palestinian Crisis: Conceptual Background and Contemporary Debate

As’ad Ghanem

45-66

The Viability of the Two-State Solution and Israeli Unilateral Intentions

Gary Sussman

67-72

The Dubious Lure of Binationalism

Salim Tamari

73-144

Towards a Sustainable Solution: Alternative Constructions for an Israeli-Palestinian Peace

Fadi Kiblawi

145-186

Alternative Palestinian Agenda - Proposal for an Alternative Configuration in Palestine-Israel

Nasser Abufarha

187-204

Finding a Just Solution for the Palestinian Refugee Problem Toward an Extra-territorial Nation-State

Sari Hanafi

205-216

Thinking about the Futures of Palestine with the Pasts of Others: Implications for the Settlements in a Two or One-State Solution

Ian Lustick

217-224

Confederation Options in the Palestine-Israel Conflict

Asher Susser

225-236

Thinking Out of the Box: Towards a Middle East Union

Jeff Halper

237-246

ISFALUR ( Israel, Falastin, and Urdun) - A Benelux Scheme

Arie Lova Eliav

247-270

Trilateral Land Exchange between Israel, the Palestinian Authority and Egypt: A Solution for Promoting Peace between Israel and the PA

Yehoshua Ben-Arieh

271-286

Federation versus Confederation in Jordanian-Palestinian Politics

Mousa Burayzat

287-298

Islam and the Bi-National State

Ahmad Abu Lafi

299-314

Partition as a Solution to Political Division: the Cases of Ireland, India and Palestine

Thomas G. Fraser

315-340

The End of the Two-State Solution – A Geo-Political Analysis

Jan de Jong

341

Appendix: Internet Resources